nintione

Remote Australia Online

Search here for evidence-based reports and resources about remote Australia
Remote Australia is a vast and complex area. To create opportunity, foster social inclusion and drive economic development in this region, you need a comprehensive knowledge base to drive change.
Remote Australia Online is exactly that. It’s an online platform that delivers authoritative research on topics that impact this region and its people, including education and its pathways, policy, business, social and cultural welfare, infrastructure, communication and natural resource management.

Remote Australia Online is for those who want to delve deeper into the complexities of remote Australia: its intricate and interconnected networks, the geographical, social, cultural and environmental influences, its opportunities, challenges, and to understand just what makes this unique region tick.
Journal Article
Are We Making Education Count in Remote Australian Communities or Just Counting Education?
Author(s):
John Guenther
Published:
2013
For quite some time the achievements of students in remote Australian schools have been lamented. There is not necessarily anything new about the relative difference between the results of Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander students in remote communities and their counterparts in urban, regional and rural schools across Australia. However, in the last decade a number of changes in the education system have led to the difference being highlighted — to such an extent that what had been an ‘othering’ of remote students (and their families) has turned into marginalisation that is described in terms of disadvantage, deficit and failure. One of the primary instruments used to reinforce this discourse has been the National Assessment Program — Literacy and Numeracy (NAPLAN) testing. This instrument has also been used as part of the justification for a policy response that sees governments attempting to close the educational gap, sometimes through punitive measures, and sometimes with incentives. At a strategic level, this is reflected in a focus on attendance, responding to the perceived disadvantage, and demanding higher standards of performance (of students, teachers and schools more generally). Accountability has resulted in lots of counting in education — counts of attendance, enrolments, dollars spent and test scores. These measures lead one to conclude that remote education is failing, that teachers need to improve their professional standards and that students need to perform better. But in the process, have we who are part of the system lost sight of the need to make education count? And if it is to count, what should it count for in remote Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander communities? These are questions that the Cooperative Research Centre for Remote Economic Participation is attempting to find answers to as part of its Remote Education Systems project. This article questions the assumptions behind the policy responses using publicly available NAPLAN data from very remote schools. It argues that the assumptions about what works in schools generally do not work in very remote schools with high proportions of Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander students. It therefore questions whether we in the system are counting the right things (for example attendance, enrolments and measures of disadvantage).
Journal Article
Learning Versus Education: Rethinking Learning in Anangu Schools
Author(s):
Sam Osborne
Published:
2013
In the remote schooling context, much recent media attention has been directed to issues of poor attendance, low attainment rates of minimal benchmarks in literacy and numeracy, poor retention and the virtual absence of transitions from school to work. The Australian government's recent ‘Gonski review’ (Review of Funding for Schooling – Final Report 2011) also strongly advocates the need to increase investment and effort into remote education across Australia in order to address the concerns of under-achievement, particularly of Indigenous students. Large-scale policies designed to improve access to services have caused a significant increase in services delivered from external sources, policy development at all levels of government, and tight accountability measures that affect remote communities and in turn, schools in various ways. Remote educators find themselves caught in the middle of this systemic discourse and the voices and values that exist in the remote communities where they live. Within this complex environment, the purpose of this article is to amplify Indigenous community voices and values in the discourse and by doing so, challenge ourselves as educators and educational leaders to examine the question: ‘While we're busy delivering education, is anybody learning anything?’ This article focuses on the Anangu (Pitjantjatjara/Yankunytjatjara) context of the North-West of South Australia, southern regions of the Northern Territory and into Western Australia. This region is referred to as the ‘tri-state’ region. Using a qualitative methodology, this article examines three Pitjantjatjara language oral narrative transcripts where Anangu reflect on their experiences of growing up and learning. By privileging these Anangu voices in the dialogue about learning in the remote Aboriginal community context, key themes are identified and analysed, highlighting important considerations for remote educators in understanding the values and cultural elements that inform Anangu students in their engagement with a formal education context.
Journal Article
Kulintja Nganampa Maa-kunpuntjaku (Strengthening Our Thinking): Place-Based Approaches to Mental Health and Wellbeing in Anangu Schools
Author(s):
Sam Osborne
Published:
2013
MindMatters, implemented by Principals Australia Institute, is a resource and professional development initiative supporting Australian secondary schools in promoting and protecting the mental health and social and emotional wellbeing of members of school communities, preferring a proactive paradigm (Covey, 1989) to the position of ‘disaster response’. While the MindMatters national focus has continued, grown and become embedded in schools since its beginning in 2000, MindMatters staff have also specifically sought to establish localised mental health and wellbeing (MHWB) promotion in Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander communities that empowers local school and community groups to build on community values and intergenerational capacities for supporting the MHWB of young people. This article outlines the processes for successful practice that have been developed in a very remote Aboriginal school context, and highlights the strengths and benefits of this approach from the perspectives of Anangu (Pitjantjatjara/Yankunytjatjara people of Central Australia) educators. Using a community development approach, Anangu educators, skilled linguists, community members and MindMatters trained staff formed learning communities that recontextualised MHWB curriculum to be taught in Anangu schools. While critically reflecting on the process MindMatters has adopted, this article draws on the voices of Anangu to privilege the cultural philosophical positions in the discourse. In so doing, important principles for translating what is fundamentally a western knowledge system's construct into corresponding Anangu knowledge systems is highlighted. Through building on the knowledge base that exists in the community context, Anangu educators, school staff and community members develop confidence, shared language and capacity to become the expert educators, taking their knowledge and resources to other Anangu school communities to begin their MindMatters journey ‘Anangu way’. This process supports students as they engage in the school-based activities and build a language for reflecting on MHWB concerns, leading them to learn and practice ‘better ways of thinking and acting’ (Kulintja Palyantja Palya —the Pitjantjatjara language title for the MindMatters, ‘Anangu Way’ program).
Report
Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander Art Economies project: Literature review
Author(s):
Acker, T; Stefanoff, L; Woodhead, A
Published:
2013
Publisher:
Ninti One Limited
This literature review surveys writing about the Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander art and craft sector of remote Australia. The review has been compiled as a foundational text for the ‘Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander Art Economies’ research project being undertaken by the CRC for Remote Economic Participation (CRC-REP). The Art Economies Project (AEP) is a unique opportunity to investigate, analyse and enhance key points of exchange within the sector, many of which are poorly understood, under-researched and characterised by different kinds of fragility or instability. The sector is a significant contributor to the cultural and social life of Australia and simultaneously creates important enterprise and employment opportunities for remote-area Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander people. Broadly, Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander people are more likely to be employed in visual arts and crafts occupations as their main job (52%) than non-Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander people (9.7%) (ABS2006), and investments in Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander arts centres generate positive financial returns to artists, calculated at a ratio of approximately 1:5 (Commonwealth of Australia2007a). This review is linked to the primary zones in which AEP research will take place, presenting the current understanding and gaps in each of the six areas of interest: the scope and scale of the sector; the business of remote-area art centres; artists and art business outside of art centres; marketing and consumer dynamics; remote area human resources; and e-commerce and licensing. Publications describing the aesthetic, social, cultural and economic dynamics of the Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander art economy have been generated by a broad range of people, from economists to anthropologists, art historians to art dealers. This diversity creates challenges in assembling an encompassing literature review. Despite the range of material, however, it is also clear that there are sizeable and important gaps in knowledge about the art economy. These gaps range from understanding the size of, and financial flows within, the sector through to the barriers for remote enterprise and the opportunities for (and obstacles within) new marketing and business models. In contrast to the knowledge gaps about the commercial forces at work is a considerable body of research into the social and cultural worlds of remote area art and artists. Recent years have seen a major contraction in the art economy. The Office of the Registrar of Indigenous Corporation reports a 52.1% reduction in sales in remote art centres (Commonwealth of Australia 2012:2) since 2007, which accords with other anecdotal industry information as to the fragility within the sector. Understanding this fragility and the potential for expanding the success of the art economy, lie at the nucleus of the AEP’s research work.
Conference Paper
Red dirt thinking on educational disadvantage
Author(s):
Guenther J.; Osborne S.; Bat M.
Published:
2013
The discourse of remote education is often characterised by a rhetoric of disadvantage. This is reflected in statistics that on the surface seem unambiguous in their demonstration of poor outcomes for remote Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander students. A range of data support this view, including National Action Plan for Literacy and Numeracy (NAPLAN) achievement data, school attendance data, Australian Bureau of Statistics Census data and other compilations such as the Productivity Commission’s biennial Overcoming Disadvantage Report. These data, briefly summarised in this paper, paint a bleak picture of the state of education in remote Australia and are at least in part responsible for a number of government initiatives (state, territory and Commonwealth) designed to ‘close the gap’. However, for all the rhetoric about disadvantage and the emphasis in strategic policy terms about activities designed to ‘close the gap’, the results of the numerous programs seem to suggest that the progress, as measured in the data, is too slow to make any significant difference to the apparent disparity between remote Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander schools and those in the broader community. We are left with a discourse that is replete with illustrations of poor outcomes and failures and does little to acknowledge the richness, diversity and achievement of those living in remote Australia. This paper critiques the idea of ‘disadvantage’ and ‘advantage’ as it is constructed in policy and consequently reported in data. Its purpose is to propose alternative ways of thinking about remote educational disadvantage, based on the early observations of a five year Cooperative Research Centre for Remote Economic Participation project. It asks, how might relative advantage be defined if the ontologies, axiologies, epistemologies and cosmologies of remote Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander families were more fully taken into account in the education system’s discourse within/of remote schooling. Based on what we have termed ‘red dirt thinking’ it goes on to propose alternative measures of success that could be applied in remote contexts where ways of knowing, being, doing, believing and valuing often differ considerably from what the educational system imposes on it.
Conference Paper
Are we making education count in remote Australian communities or just counting education?
Author(s):
Guenther, J
Published:
2012
For quite some time the achievements of students in remote Australian schools have been lamented. There is not necessarily anything new about the relative difference between the results of Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander students in remote communities and their counterparts in urban, regional and rural schools across Australia. However, in the last decade a number of changes in the education system have led to the difference being highlighted—to such an extent that what had been an ‘othering’ of remote students (and their families) has turned into marginalisation which is described in terms of disadvantage, deficit and failure. One of the primary instruments used to reinforce this discourse has been National Action Plan for Literacy and Numeracy (NAPLAN) testing. This instrument has also been used as part of the justification for a policy response that sees governments attempting to close the educational gap, sometimes through punitive measures, and sometimes with incentives. At a strategic level, this is reflected in a focus on attendance, responding to the perceived disadvantage, and demanding higher standards of performance (of students, teachers and schools more generally). Accountability has resulted in lots of counting in education—counts of attendance, enrolments, dollars spent and test scores. These measures lead one to conclude that remote education is failing, that teachers need to improve their professional standards and that students need to perform better. But in the process, have we who are part of the system lost sight of the need to make education count? And if it is to count, what should it count for in remote Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander communities? These are questions that the Cooperative Research Centre for Remote Economic Participation is attempting to find answers to as part of its Remote Education Systems project. This presentation questions the assumptions behind the policy responses using publicly available NAPLAN data from very remote schools. It argues that the assumptions about what works in schools generally, do not work in very remote schools with high proportions of Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander students. It therefore questions whether we in the system are counting the right things (for example attendance, enrolments and measures of disadvantage).
Conference Paper
FIFO, Flexibility, and the Future: Does Becoming a Regional FIFO Source Community Present Opportunity or Burden?
Author(s):
Fiona McKenzie; Aileen Hoath
Published:
2013
Publisher:
Regional Science Association
The resources boom in Australia resulted in considerable competition for both skilled and unskilled labour, particularly in remote mining areas. Shortage of skilled labour led mining companies to source workers from far afield, while the high incomes created by a tight labour market drew labour from across the country through long distance commuting arrangements such as fly-in, fly-out (FIFO) and drive-in, drive-out (DIDO). While much recent literature has focussed on the impacts on receiving communities of these long distance commuters, less attention has been given to the experience of source communities. This paper compares the situation between two regional towns in which long distance commuters reside. The first, Busselton in Western Australia, is among several chosen by Rio Tinto to be labour source communities. The second, Stawell in Victoria, is looking to long distance commuting as a response to the impending closure of their existing gold mine. Hence the case studies offer insights, not only about source communities' experience of FIFO and DIDO, but also a comparison between the bottom-up approach of Stawell in trying to establish FIFO with the experience of Busselton which has been chosen (top-down) by a mining company for labour sourcing. This paper will consider the opportunities the Rio Tinto employment strategy offers to rural and regional communities which are keen to retain their population. The paper will highlight some community development challenges which have been encountered and how these might be addressed, especially by towns such as Stawell which is seeking to promote itself as a source community for skilled mining employment.
Conference Paper
Towards educational advantage in very remote Australia: An analysis of 2012 NAPLAN data: what does it tell us about remote education in the last five years?
Author(s):
John Guenther
Published:
2013
Publisher:
Australian Association for Research in Education
For five years now, a national testing program has been conducted in Australia. While there has been much agitation and concern about the merit of this program, particularly for students in very remote Australia, it remains a cornerstone of the Measurement Framework for Schooling in Australia. The National Assessment Program provides a basis for measuring improvement against the goals of the 2008 Melbourne Declaration on Educational Goals for Young Australians and subsequently the National Education Agreement, which embodies a range of Council of Australian Governments (COAG) goals and targets, including Closing the Gap targets. After five years it might be expected that the data would show some change. The Cooperative Research Centre for Remote Economic Participation's Remote Education Systems project is midway through a five year research program, which is particularly interested in outcomes for Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander students who live in remote communities. To this end, the project has used existing publicly available data drawn from the MySchool website to determine what has happened for schools in very remote Australia. The analysis shows that for very remote schools enrolments are trending down for both schools with greater than 80 per cent Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander student population and also those with less. Similarly, average school size is tending to fall for both groups. School attendance rates have not changed significantly over the five years. Reading scores at any year have not changed significantly over the five years for either group of schools or for any jurisdiction. Numeracy scores have declined significantly for year 3 in schools with greater than 80 per cent Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander students. The decline was significant at a jurisdictional level for Queensland and the Northern Territory. Year 7 numeracy scores have declined significantly for schools with up to 80 per cent Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander students. While a large part of this paper is devoted to presenting the findings of the analysis, the broader aim of the paper is to question what the findings might mean for the provision of an advantageous education for remote Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander students. It raises questions about issues of accountability, equity and how success might be better defined.
Conference Paper
Education is the key, but do we need to change the locks?
Author(s):
John Guenther
Published:
2013
This paper examines the nature of educational and employment outcomes for Aboriginal people in very remote Northern Territory. In particular, the differences between those(according to Australian Bureau of Statistics definitions) who speak a local language at home and those who speak English are considered. The analysis is based on a review of 2011 Census data The purpose of the analysis is to assess the impact of cultural alignments on participation in mainstream economies that exist in very remote parts of the Territory. It also questions to what extent the demands of industries are aligned to higher level schooling and post-school qualifications. Does education open the doors we expect it to? The findings add to qualitative and quantitative analysis already undertaken as part of the Cooperative Research Centre for Remote Economic Participation’s Remote Education Systems (RES) project. They shed light on the use of constructs such as ‘Indigenous disadvantage’ and policy initiatives designed to close ‘gaps’. At the end of the presentation, a number of alternative strategic and experimental models will be outlined that emerge in response to the challenges arising from these and other findings from the RES project. The intention of these models is to promote alternative approaches to education policy and practice, particularly for Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander students from very remote communities.
Journal Article
Economic rationality in choosing between short-term bad-health choices and longer-term good-health choices
Author(s):
David Campbell
Published:
2013
Non-contagious, chronic disease has been identified as a global health risk. Poor lifestyle choices, such as smoking, alcohol, drug and solvent abuse, physical inactivity, and unhealthy diet have been identified as important factors affecting the increasing incidence of chronic disease. The following focuses on the circumstance affecting the lifestyle or behavioral choices of Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander peoples in remote-/very remote Australia. Poor behavioral choices are the result of endogenous characteristics that are influenced by a range of stressful exogenous variables making up the psychosocial determinants including social disenfranchisement, cultural loss, insurmountable tasks, the loss of volitional control and resource constraints. It is shown that poor behavioral choices can be economically rational; especially under highly stressful conditions. Stressful circumstances erode individual capacity to commit to long-term positive health alternatives such as self-investment in education. Policies directed at removing the impediments and providing incentives to behaviors involving better health choices can lead to reductions in smoking and alcohol consumption and improved health outcomes. Multijurisdictional culturally acceptable policies directed at distal variables relating to the psychosocial determinants of health and personal mastery and control can be cost effective. While the content of this paper is focused on the conditions of colonized peoples, it has broader relevance.
Thesis
Cultural Icons and Cash Commodities: The Two-World Story of Australian Bush Foods
Author(s):
Cleary, Jennifer
Published:
2014
Publisher:
University of South Australia
Uniquely Australian flora and fauna, known as ‘bushfood’ or ‘bush tucker’ plays an important role in the daily lives of many Aboriginal peoples, particularly those living in remote Australia. Bush food provides a valuable contribution to diet, is used as a mechanism for passing on traditional knowledge about caring for country and being part of country. Specific plants and animals intrinsically linked to particular locations are thus culturally important to Aboriginal peoples and their country, from which place-based identity is derived. Products derived from bush foods also form the basis of the Australian bush foods industry where a growing domestic and international market is creating increased demand for raw supply from both wild-harvest and cultivation of many species of plants and animals. This research explored the nature of participation of remote Aboriginal peoples in the bush foods industry, and their positions in bush foods value chains. The study further explored the ways in which participatory action research (PAR) might be used as a vehicle for engagement of Aboriginal peoples in ongoing development in remote Australia. The research found that considerations of what constitutes ‘value’ in relation to bush foods might differ, according to worldview. Remote Aboriginal peoples attribute both socio-cultural and economic value to bush foods. These multiple considerations of value are important, in that they impact upon the ways in which remote Aboriginal peoples are engaging in the bush foods industry and the manner in which they may engage in the future. This finding may also have implications for other industries in which remote Aboriginal people are engaged, e.g. the art and tourism sectors. The research makes a unique contribution to developing new knowledge through the development and articulation of a framework that incorporates the domains of land, actions, relationships and commodities (LARC) in the construction of value. The LARC Value framework enables considerations of both economic and non-economic value representations in bush foods value chains.
Conference Paper
Learning pathways for economic enterprise in remote Aboriginal communities: are Certificate IIIs the ticket?
Author(s):
Eva McRae-Williams; John Guenther
Published:
2014
Publisher:
Australian Vocational Education and Training Research Association
For many of us, when conjuring up a picture of very remote Aboriginal Australia, our images are drawn from a common storehouse of disadvantage, where the consequences of low levels of education, and high rates of unemployment, shade the environment with unpleasant tones. From this position it is not difficult to see why ‘closing the gap’ in education and employment outcomes directs our future imagining for Aboriginal and/or Torres Strait Islander peoples. If only we could get more people finishing school, achieving VET qualifications at certificate three or above then in the future more people would be able to get jobs, and their lives would reflect something better. But is this picture one that has been built up from the evidence or one that is more rooted in the ground of common and often unquestioned assumptions? Is holding a certificate the most valid or effective ticket needed for supporting people along their livelihood pathways? As part of the Cooperative Research Centre for Remote Economic Participation (NintiOne) ‘Pathways to Employment’ project, this paper will provide a brief snap shot of remote Australia using the 2011 Census Data. By reviewing current VET qualifications and industry profiles questions will be raised about the assumed positive link between formal qualification and employment outcomes. This link with be further problematized through drawing on case study findings associated with a non-formal, non-accredited learning approach to microenterprise development in very remote Aboriginal Australia. Arguing that much of the VET sector is shaped by certain employment centric values which see human capital delivery models privileged, this paper highlights the significance of more holistic vocational and adult education models which acknowledge local agency and place the development of social and identity capital at their core. The paper will conclude by emphasising the need for the national VET system to re-imagine its role in remote Aboriginal communities from primarily the delivery of human capital competencies to the facilitation of learning spaces that build identity and agency.
Conference Paper
Amplifying the voice of remote Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander VET stakeholders using research methodologies: Volume 1.
Author(s):
John Guenther; Sam Osborne; Allan Arnott; Eva McRae-Williams; Samantha Disbray
Published:
2014
Publisher:
Australian Vocational Education and Training Research Association
Researchers in remote Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander contexts within Australia are frequently faced with the challenges of working in an intercultural space where channels of communication are garbled with interference created by the complexities of misunderstood worldviews, languages, values and expectations. A concern of many researchers in these contexts is to ensure that the voices of research participants in remote communities are not only accurately represented, but are allowed to transcend the noise of dominant paradigms, policies and practices. This paper brings together the experiences of five researchers in the space of remote vocational education and training. The authors present three vignettes from research in the context of health, employment and education. These vignettes highlight some of the conundrums for researchers as they attempt to harmonise the aims of research with the expectations of organisations involved. Wrapped around these vignettes, the authors highlight the progressive thinking associated with Indigenist and culturally responsive methodologies, and draw together conclusions that may assist other researchers in their attempts to find ways that support the credibility, integrity and validity of the research process while at the same time doing the same for the voices of remote Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander participants.
There are no available cars matching the current filters.
Reset All