nintione

Remote Australia Online

Search here for evidence-based reports and resources about remote Australia
Remote Australia is a vast and complex area. To create opportunity, foster social inclusion and drive economic development in this region, you need a comprehensive knowledge base to drive change.
Remote Australia Online is exactly that. It’s an online platform that delivers authoritative research on topics that impact this region and its people, including education and its pathways, policy, business, social and cultural welfare, infrastructure, communication and natural resource management.

Remote Australia Online is for those who want to delve deeper into the complexities of remote Australia: its intricate and interconnected networks, the geographical, social, cultural and environmental influences, its opportunities, challenges, and to understand just what makes this unique region tick.
Report
Aborigines and Uranium: Monitoring the Health Hazards
Author(s):
Colin Tatz; Alan Cass; John Condon; George Tippett
Published:
2006
Publisher:
Australian Institute of Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander Studies; Native Title Research Unit
The Uranium Mining, Processing and Nuclear Energy Review Draft Report deals with Health and Safety issues (Chapter 6) and with Environmental Impacts (Chapter 7). At p.63, the report states that ‘there are legacy problems associated with the Nuclear industry’, and that ‘protecting the people must be a high priority’. The report notes that ‘there may be incidents at the mines that give rise to non-routine radiation exposure’ and that at Ranger ‘incidents occurred in 1983 and 2004’ (p.71). In this context, the Review raises the complex question of how risk is perceived, and how the public and the experts at times have different perceptions of risk. This paper specifically addresses several of the issues that come within the Review’s terms of reference. It may differ from most of the submissions and consultations to date in that it deals with essentially one critical case study of a definable Aboriginal community living in the vicinity of uranium mining and milling. But it also offers a positive model for the ongoing monitoring of health protection and prevention measures that could be adopted for uranium mining operations elsewhere in Australia. Uranium has been mined and milled in a Northern Territory Aboriginal domain — the Kakadu Region — for the past three decades, ostensibly under ‘strictly controlled conditions’. Have uranium operations adversely affected Aboriginal health in the Region? High doses of radiation are known to cause cancers, foetal damage, congenital malformations and even to retard cognitive development. We know less about the effects of low doses, but any community-protection program must assume some degree of health risk. Radiation can enter the body by ingestion of local food and water, by inhaling radioactive gases and airborne dust, and by irradiation from external sources. Since 1981, three years after mining began, at least 120 ‘mishaps’ and ‘occurrences’ — leakages, spillages of contaminated water, and breaches of regulations — have occurred. The Office of the Supervising Scientist has consistently claimed no harm to either the environment or human health — a claim difficult to substantiate. Since completion of the AIATSIS social impact monitoring report in 1984, there has been no monitoring of the social and physical impact on Aboriginal health and well-being, and no agency has specifically investigated the impacts on Aboriginal health. Exploratory research undertaken in 2005 and 2006 has found a significant overall increase in the incidence of cancer among Aboriginal people in the Kakadu region — some ninety per cent greater than would be expected. We could not determine possible effects on maternal and child health because data on congenital malformations and stillbirths were not available. Existing data sets are not adequate to identify a definitive cause for the increased cancer incidence. There could be reasons for the high cancer rates other than proximity to uranium mining and milling. However, in the light of this lack of knowledge, we submit that there is an urgent need for continued, comprehensive monitoring of health wherever uranium mining occurs, and for at least twenty years after mines cease operation. Our suggested model for ongoing monitoring would cost a few hundred thousand dollars per year. The proposal is neither radical nor expensive. It makes better sense — in human, political, economic and, eventually, legal terms — to monitor and to control potential hazards than to treat the toxic effects of radiation exposure.
Report
Communal land and the amendments to the Aboriginal Land Rights Act (NT)
Author(s):
Michael Dodson; Diana McCarthy
Published:
2006
Publisher:
Australian Institute of Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander Studies; Native Title Research Unit
I’m all for a robust debate on the merits of different approaches. But at last it seems that maybe we are slowly moving away from some of the old entrenched ideological positions in Indigenous affairs and towards a more business-like appraisal of the benefits for Indigenous people (Vanstone 2005). This paper is written as a response to the former Federal Aboriginal Affairs Minister Amanda Vanstone’s call for ‘robust debate’ on the Howard Government’s ‘quiet revolution’ in Aboriginal Affairs. It takes as its focus the amendments to the Aboriginal Land Rights Act (Northern Territory)1976 (hereafter ‘the ALRA’), in particular the proposal to establish a mechanism to effectively privatise areas of Aboriginal land. We oppose this amendment as a simplistic attempt at social engineering, which proceeds on premises that are ideologically driven and without evidentiary basis. Our reasons are as follows. There has been no opportunity for the relevant traditional owners to give their free, prior and informed consent to this amendment. There is adequate provision in the existing legislation for the issuing of leases where and when this is desired by these people. There is evidence-based research which clearly demonstrates that most Indigenous households in remote communities do not have the resources to service a mortgage, such that bankruptcy rather than home-ownership is a more likely outcome of this policy. We believe that Indigenous Australians have a right to self-determination and that this right includes the right to forms of tenure that reflect cultural difference.
Report
Back to Redfern: autonomy and the 'Middle E' in relation to Aboriginal health
Author(s):
Hunter, Ernest
Published:
2006
Publisher:
Australian Institute of Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander Studies; Native Title Research Unit
ABC’s flagship current affairs program PM for 21 June 2006, juxtaposed three Indigenous items. The first recorded the launch in Canberra of Australia’s Health 2006 by the Commonwealth government minister of health, Tony Abbott, in which he called for a new form of paternalism (“a paternalism based on competence rather than race”) to address unrelenting Indigenous health problems associated with failed past policies including ‘self-determination’. The item also included the immediate reactions of Indigenous spokespersons who, in noting that self-determination had never been realised in practice, objected strenuously to further erosions of autonomy. The second item presented evidence of adults exchanging petrol for sex with children and young people, and the impunity of perpetrators, in Central Australian Aboriginal communities. Perhaps to mitigate the sombre tone of these two stories, the third item recounted the successes of the Aboriginal Employment Strategy in providing real employment opportunities for Aboriginal residents of Moree. Paternalism, autonomy, vulnerability, opportunity – these terms are ambiguous and contentious in relation to Indigenous affairs. While the terms are malleable to political purposes the concepts involved are critical in terms of Indigenous health and all relate to the fundamental issue of ‘control of destiny’. This discussion paper is based on the Redfern Oration to doctors of the Australasian Faculty of Public Health Medicine (Cairns, 9 May 2006). In it I frame discussion of these and related concepts by challenging medical practitioners to consider what striving for a just society means in relation to Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander health. Conventional conceptions of medical ethics fail to resolve competing values and responsibilities at the clinical coal-face, and I draw on the concept of ‘fair equality of opportunity’, which emphasises the critical importance of education and health as social determinants and social rights. I highlight the importance of child development and use Indigenous suicide to exemplify the impact of disrupting the neuropsycho-social developmental milieu, and the consequences of this across generations. Suicide also illustrates the problems associated with the medicalisation of complex social issues and the narrow conceptualisation of ‘risk’. For medical practitioners, the particular vulnerabilities of Aboriginal children raise challenging ethical questions, both in terms of prioritising social goals over patient needs, and in regard to paternalistic interventionism. This is, of course, a critical issue for a profession in which paternalism is inevitable. In this regard, I consider the difference between paternalism that supports autonomy and paternalism that undermines autonomy, particularly as it relates to the critical issue of real ‘control of destiny’.
Report
Indigenous Governance The Harvard Project on Native American Economic Development and appropriate principles of governance for Aboriginal Australia
Author(s):
Patrick Sullivan
Published:
2006
Publisher:
Australian Institute of Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander Studies; Native Title Research Unit
It is widely acknowledged that indigenous communities in Australia are in crisis (Dodson 2003; Sutton 2001), and increasingly that this is a crisis of governance. Anthropological analysis of pre-colonial Aboriginal political life has characterised it as ‘ordered anarchy’ (Hiatt 1998). The introduction of order into anarchy results from the tension between relatedness and autonomy mediated by an ideology of nurturing (Myers 1986). Colonisation of Australia resulted in the coercion of Aboriginal people into settlements - either missions or pastoral enterprises. Since de jure emancipation settlements have been nominally under Aboriginal control (Sullivan 1996). The conundrum for post-colonial public policy in Australia, that this paper addresses, is how to effectively service Aboriginal people’s needs, encourage the good governance that self-determination requires, institute regimes of respect for civil and human rights within these communities and still remain sensitive to the fact of a continuing lively Aboriginal culture informed by pre-colonial forms of sociality. The Harvard Project on Indian Economic Development (US) appears to hold out the hope of a post-colonial indigenised governance attractive to both government and indigenous interests. It proposes that there are three prerequisites for development in indigenous communities: sovereignty, good institutions (meaning, in this instance, good management), and cultural match (Jorgensen and Taylor 2000; Cornell 2002; Dodson and Smith 2003). This paper takes the Harvard project’s prescriptions as problems rather than solutions and asks whether they are reconcilable with Aboriginal political life. Indigenous communities are clearly embedded in post-colonial settler relations in multiple ways (Benhabib 2002; Tully 1995:10-11; Waldron 1992). Authority in indigenous life, as much as in post-colonial administration, is layered, contextual, contested and continuously subject to exegesis such that both the totality of the settler state and the essentialised nature of indigenous groups that confront it are called in question (Martin 2003:2-6). It is not adequate, this paper suggests, to conceive of Aboriginal culture as a set of institutions that can be translated, in one way or another, into effective organisational structures for self-management or commerce. It proposes disentangling Aboriginal cultural processes from effective organisational structures and linking these only through lines of information sharing, and permission-getting, that is by engagement with communal political processes. Added to this is the need for protection of minority and dissident interests by providing guidelines for the acceptable exercise of authority within an Aboriginal domain. This paper looks for ways of meeting three competing aims: effective indigenous governance, respect for indigenous culture, and acknowledgement of the need for human and civil rights within indigenous communities that reflect the fact that they are embedded in a wider sociality.
Report
Not fit for modern Australian society: Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander people and the new arrangements for the administration of Indigenous affairs
Author(s):
Kerry Arabena
Published:
2005
Publisher:
Australian Institute of Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander Studies; Native Title Research Unit
In the discussions about the Shared Responsibility Agreement (SRA) negotiated with the Mulan community, the Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander Social Justice Commissioner, Tom Calma stated that: - It would be unacceptable for Indigenous people to be denied basic citizenship services that all Australians take for granted...any proposals must comply fully with the Racial Discrimination Act and the principle of non-discrimination more generally. Proposals which fail to do so should be rejected outright as morally repugnant and not fit for modern Australian society. Jackie Huggins made an argument to the Senate that there is a need to reflect on, and analyse the new approaches to Indigenous affairs, and our responses to them. Jackie also suggests that: - Change is fine – as long as it makes sense and isn’t change for the sake of it or even worse change for purely political reasons that bear little relevance to the daily lives of my people. The complexities of the new arrangements are difficult to communicate in their entirety, however, we need to consider the impact of the new arrangements because, as the then ATSIC Commissioner Alison Anderson has forewarned us all: - -The potentially destructive impact of the move away from self-determination to mainstreaming will be seen in the immediate future. Our concern is that once again we will be experimented on and that, in another five to ten years’ time, we will be back to discuss what went wrong. This paper then, is one Indigenous woman’s reflection and analysis of the first twelve months in the new arrangements in the administration of Indigenous affairs. This paper is in three sections: Section A outlines the policy evolution and background to the new arrangements in the administration of Indigenous affairs and provides an overview of the arguments expressed by Aboriginal leaders and their inclusion in the new policy framework. In this section I attempt to answer the questions: What are the new arrangements in Indigenous affairs? Are the new arrangements really new? What is the Government’s plan? Section B details the new arrangements and provides an analysis of the primary and secondary client group of the new arrangements, as well as issues pertaining to Indigenous people’s representation and strategic leadership; and a review of emerging inequities by using case studies. In this section I attempt to answer the question: How are the new arrangements effected through policy and actions of Government? Section C explains the potential impact of the new arrangements on Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander peoples and a way forward. In this section I try to articulate what these arrangements mean for Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander peoples and provide some strategies to consider for positioning ourselves into the future. I consider the questions: What might the impact of these new arrangements be on Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander peoples’ aspirations for self-determination and how can we respond?
Report
The Limitations of Litigation in Stolen Generations Cases
Author(s):
Chris Cunneen; Julia Grix
Published:
2004
Publisher:
Australian Institute of Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander Studies; Native Title Research Unit
The purpose of this Discussion Paper is to review the progress of litigation by members of the Stolen Generations before the courts in Australia. The National Inquiry into the Separation of Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander Children from Their Families found that forcible removal breached a range of domestic laws and international human rights standards. Yet, despite this finding, court action by members of the Stolen Generations has been unsuccessful. It is our purpose to consider these failures in more detail. This Discussion Paper sets out the key applicants and their legal claims, followed by the various and, at times, unique difficulties confronting Stolen Generation claimants before the courts. Our analysis is from a socio-legal perspective that places in context the experiences of Indigenous persons who have sought to use the legal system. The major limitations of the litigation process which we identify include the problem of overcoming statutory limitation periods, the difficulty of locating evidence, the emotional and psychological trauma experienced by claimants in the hostile environment of an adversarial court system, the enormous financial cost and time involved, the problem of establishing specific liability for harms that have been caused, and the problem of overcoming the judicial view that ‘standards of the time’ justified removal in the best interests of the child. We conclude by noting the importance of alternative approaches to achieving justice for the Stolen Generations.
Report
The Business of Process: Research Issues in Managing Indigenous Decision-Making and Disputes in Land
Author(s):
Toni Bauman; Rhiân Williams
Published:
2004
Publisher:
Australian Institute of Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander Studies; Native Title Research Unit
The Indigenous Facilitation and Mediation Project at the Australian Institute of Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander Studies is aimed at researching best practice Indigenous decision-making and dispute management systems and building on Indigenous skills and approaches in these areas to develop training for Indigenous peoples. In developing Indigenous governance approaches, including decision-making and dispute management processes in Indigenous communities, there has been a tendency to transplant processes from the non-Indigenous context. This paper argues that developing localised approaches to decision-making and dispute management that are responsive to the needs of Indigenous communities is essential, particularly as the approaches which are adopted can escalate or exacerbate fundamental pressures and tensions within Indigenous groups. The ongoing evaluation of the effectiveness and consequences of the range of processes which are implemented is also critical. This is particularly the case, given that the emphasis of the amended Native Title Act 1993 is on agreement-making and maximising ‘outcomes’ through non-adversarial and collaborative alternative dispute resolution mechanisms such as mediation and facilitation. This paper emphasises that in order to get ‘outcomes’, the first thing is to get the process right. This includes ensuring that appropriately authorised locally based Indigenous decision-making and representative processes are core components of effective and sustainable collaborative and co-operative efforts.
Report
Constitutional reform and its relationship with land justice
Author(s):
Sean Brennan
Published:
2011
Publisher:
Australian Institute of Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander Studies; Native Title Research Unit
The Australian government has made a commitment to a referendum on constitutional recognition of Australia’s first peoples. In a series of two papers, Land, Rights, Laws: Issues of Native Title, will explore where native title might fit into this debate. In this paper, native title specialist Sean Brennan outlines five possible areas of constitutional change and discusses their practical implications for native title. While many key legal settings for native title are already in place, recent history tells us that important legislative and judicial choices about Indigenous land justice will continue to be made in coming years and that constitutional arrangements will exert a significant shaping influence on the outcome. A range of viable proposals for constitutional reform are presently under consideration for a 2013 referendum which could materially affect the future pursuit of land justice for first peoples in Australia. These include, in particular, a non-discrimination clause with respect to race, which allows for positive Indigenous-specific laws, including ones enacted under a revised power in section 51(xxvi) of the Constitution, and a constitutional provision to support agreement-making between governments and Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander people.
Report
Housing on native title lands: responses to the housing amendments of the Native Title Act
Author(s):
Claire Stacey; Joe Fardin
Published:
2011
Publisher:
Australian Institute of Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander Studies; Native Title Research Unit
In 2009, the Federal Government proposed to amend the Native Title Act 1993 (Cth) to expedite the provision of public housing and infrastructure for remote Indigenous communities. Originally introduced as the Native Title Amendment Bill (No.2) 2009 in October 2009, the amendments were passed into legislation as the Native Title Amendment Act (No.1) 2010 in November 2010. This paper provides a summary of the issues raised in response to the amendments that emerged through the initial parliamentary consultation process and Senate inquiry. The amendments are an attempt to mediate the complexity of public housing provision on native title lands, yet the submissions represented a lack of wider support for the changes. The submissions base their opposition on: a lack of evidence to support the underlying claims; legal uncertainties of the proposed amendments within the broader legal landscape of native title; inadequate provisions for consultation contained in the amendments; the issue of non-extinguishment; issues of racial discrimination; and the exclusion of any criticism of the bureaucratic processes that contribute to delays in public housing provision. The negative responses to the amendments broadly criticise the Federal, State and Territory Governments’ continued misinterpretation of the role of native title in supporting Indigenous development and well-being.
Report
Written proof: the appropriation of genealogical records in contemporary Arrernte society
Author(s):
Rebecca Morgan; Helen Wilmot
Published:
2010
Publisher:
Australian Institute of Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander Studies; Native Title Research Unit
For decades, anthropologists working in the Northern Territory have prepared written materials, including genealogies. These materials form evidence in land claim and native title proceedings, as well as the basis for standard research and consultation work of land council anthropologists. Increasingly, traditional owners and native title holders, aware of the significance attached to anthropological documents, are utilising genealogical material within negotiations over land ownership. This paper discusses the growing trend among the Arrernte in Central Australia to assert and attempt to validate connection to land through the use of genealogies. Over the past few years, there has been a notable increase in disputes over competing claims that purport to be ‘proven’ by reference to genealogical records. In incidents involving disputes over land ownership, genealogies are being used as a new form of objectified authority. The use of these materials raises many questions about the production, interpretation, ownership and application of genealogical information. This paper attempts to address some of the implications ensuing from the distribution of genealogical information in a modern context, drawing on field experience to highlight some of the complex dynamics and challenges that result. The views expressed in this paper are those of the authors and do not necessarily reflect the views of the Central Land Council.
Report
The Family Connection when a Charity is for the Advancement of Indigenous Peoples: Australia and New Zealand compared
Author(s):
Fiona Martin; Audrey Sharp
Published:
2009
Publisher:
Australian Institute of Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander Studies; Native Title Research Unit
In both Australia and New Zealand various tax concessions are granted to entities that are considered ‘charitable’ or ‘charities’. For example, in Australia s 50-1 of the Income Tax Assessment Act, 1997 (Cth) provides that the income of certain entities (which includes Australian charitable entities) is exempt from income tax. In New Zealand there are similar provisions in the Income Tax Act 2007 (NZ). In order to be considered a charity under the general law the aims of the organisation must be for the public benefit or the benefit of a section of the public. The case law provides that this restriction is not met where the organisation is aimed at assisting members of the one family, in other words where the beneficiaries are connected through blood. Such a restriction can pose problems for Australian Indigenous groups, particularly land rights or native title claimants who are defined by a family or blood connection. In New Zealand several legislative amendments have been enacted to extend the meaning of charitable purpose and overcome this restriction. This paper compares the Australian and New Zealand situations and considers the question of whether or not Australia should follow a similar path to New Zealand.
Report
Native Title in Canada and Australia post Tsilhqot’in: Shared Thinking or Ships in the Night?
Author(s):
Simon Young
Published:
2009
Publisher:
Australian Institute of Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander Studies; Native Title Research Unit
The Canadian decision of Tsilhqot’in Nation v British Columbia (BC Supreme Court, 2007) was a significant step in the resolution of a long-running timber dispute in western Canada, and the most important judicial exploration of Canadian ‘Aboriginal title’ since the watershed 2002 decision of Delgamuukw. The primary significance of this recent decision for Canada lies in its quite robust conclusions on provincial jurisdictional limitations, and its wrestle with emerging controversies over the exact areas to which the concept of Aboriginal title can attach. For Australian observers, the primary importance of the decision lies, it would seem, in the Court’s disinterest in strict ‘continuity’ inquiries, its clear and pointed confirmation of the comprehensive and contemporary nature of the Aboriginal title interest, and its dissatisfaction with jurisprudential focus on the notion of ‘society’. More broadly speaking, the Tsilhqot’in decision prompts renewed reflection on reconciliation processes in both countries, and in many ways reminds us of the self-evidently valuable nature of comparative study. This paper examines the Tsilhqot’in decision against the backdrop of the Canadian legal history, and attempts to explain its significance from both the Canadian and Australian perspectives.
Report
Plus ca change, plus c’est la meme chose? - The 2007 Amendments to the Native Title Act
Author(s):
Robert French
Published:
2008
Publisher:
Australian Institute of Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander Studies; Native Title Research Unit
The Claims Resolution Review was initiated by the Attorney-General to consider 'the dispute-resolution functions of the Court and the NNTT under the Native Title Act 1993 (Cth) and the effectiveness and efficiency of the NNTT and the Court in performing those functions. In so doing the Review assessed how the NNTT and the Court could maximise the potential for native title claims to be resolved in a quicker and less resource-intensive manner, primarily through mediation and agreement-making. The Review made a number of recommendations principally aimed at strengthening the existing presumption, found in the Act in favour of mediation before the NNTT, promoting better communication and coordination between the Court and the NNTT; removing duplication of functions between the NNTT and Court; and improving the effectiveness of NNTT mediation. Almost all the recommendations made in the Review now have legislative force through the Act (as amended by the Native Title Amendment Bill 2006). This paper focuses on the historical context of the recent amendments and the Court’s procedural response to the legislative changes and how the Court and the NNTT will continue to function efficiently and cooperatively within their respective spheres
There are no available cars matching the current filters.
Reset All